John Fairchild
1863-1871
A.G. Buel
1871-1872
George Woodhull
1873-1883
A.V.C. Schenck
1884-1887
John J. Blue
1887-1892
M. Hartwell
1892-1893
J. Countermine
1894-1897
T.S. Anderson
1895-1905
Sherman Divine
1905-1908
Otis G. Dale
1909-1911
H.C. Postlethwaite
1911-1916
John Boose
1917-1925
Leslie C. Smith
1925-1931
Charles Pier
1932-1939
Thomas Graham
1940-1945
Willard Strahl
1951-1953
Axel Pearson
1951-1953
Gifford Ruby
1953-1961
Axel Pearson
1961-1962
Charles Richey
1962-1972
Joseph Stanley
1974-1988
Clifford Haskins (Interim supply)
1989-1990
Michael Orsted
1990-2000
Jeanette Hickman (Interim supply)
2001-2002
Kathleen Dooley
2002-2007
Craig Mansur (Interim supply)
2007 – 2011
Jon Nelson (Shared with First Presbyterian Church, Menominee MI)
2011 –